Grand Canyon Raft Trip (5/22/05-6/8/05):
Last spring we were contacted by two friends, Dave Wimmer and Lorie Erikson, who were helping a permit holder organize a late May, early June Grand Canyon raft trip. Their permit holder, Herm Smith, represented a group of kayakers who were struggling to find well-equipped (rafting gear that is) folks that he would be comfortable with for his trip. He found two groups on the GCPBA website but both had been found wanting as planning advanced. Since he still needed a couple of boats and we were looking for a ride, we decided to join them. The plan was to launch at Lees Ferry and to takeout at South Cove with a vehicle shuttle of some grueling 350 miles to be done by Montgomery's River Runners Shuttle Service. This would be a 21-day trip of 296 miles. Herm had been on the waitlist for 13 years and a year of planning went into making sure his trip wasn't forfeited as approximately one-third of private trips are. As it turned out Lorie - the food diva, and Dave - the gear guy, were the glue that eventually made this trip work.
Of the sixteen folks on the trip, we knew about half of them from past river adventures. Susan and John, the Flagstaff Lupos, were already on the trip, as was Rip Blaisdale. Herm had set up a server to aid pre-trip communication and there was a flood of information and questions flying around there. I quickly found that Herm wasn't the greatest about taking advice and he seemed to want to meddle into everything rather than delegate, even when he had little direct knowledge to contribute. I came to believe that might have been part of his problem with the two rafting support groups he had already terminated. Still, everything was going well enough with the planning, Lorie and Dave were successfully dealing with his many foibles, so I drifted away for a month or two rather than get Susan and I thrown off the trip. One thing I noted at his server was that the group had appointed me the on-river Boat Captain. Their hope was I would be able to give "great advice on good campsites with shade in morning and late afternoon, and great short hikes up nearby canyons and waterfalls".
Just prior to the trip we had people on the GCPBA asking us in offline emails how we were going to cope with this wacko permit holder. To make it even more interesting, one of the women wackos on the GCPBA Yahoo group sent Herm a message about what a horrible person I was and how her group, supposedly two days behind us on the river, would not cooperate with or help any group associated with Bob Marley. Her email was so ridiculously over the top even Herm realized she was the true crazy. As I sort of expected, Herm turned out not to be the devil incarnate and was willing to take bits of advice occasionally; but best of all he was certainly not in-your-face confrontational. Behind his back the folks he brought along were telling stories about prior behavior on trips; they affectionately referred to him as the "Hermroid".
The group met in Flagstaff. Dave rushed down to Lees Ferry from Colorado with three boats and dumped them in the campground. He then drove down to Flagstaff and loaded his huge trailer with 30 or so rocket boxes of food, 4-5 coolers weighing 200-300 pounds each, and several dry boxes. Three rafts were then piled on top of this and six people road in the truck cab. One dry box was full of eggs for all the breakfasts; that's right every breakfast was going to have eggs. I'm thinking of submitting the 50 dozen or so taken to the Guinness Book of Records as soon as I get a firm count. It has to be the trip record for any group of 16 folks leaving Lees Ferry. When totally loaded, Dave's trailer springs had depressed so far the wheels were practically touching the fenders on the front axle of the tandem. That required changing the trailer hitch to a higher one so we could level the trailer some. Of course, the permit holder was missing while all of this was going on. Our drive to Lees Ferry was taken slowly but went uneventfully. We arrived to find all of the equipment that Dave had dropped earlier in the fisherman's campground moved to the launch area. Rigging was well under way.
Lees Ferry is a historic Mormon crossing at the head of Marble Canyon, a vertical walled upper reach of the Grand Canyon that stretches some 60 miles down the Colorado to the Little Colorado. There were nine commercial outfitters plus us rigging boats on May 21. It took about five hours of steady work by all to get the boats ready to pass muster with Ranger Dave the next day and make sure we hadn't forgotten anything important. It was hot, tiring work! Since Dave had the loads all assigned and we knew our gear pretty well, Susan and I were able to rig quickly. After sorting the remaining gear for a while and offering a helping hand as needed, we launched our two rafts and drifted down to the private rafters' camping beach to set up our tent and get into the shade of those skinny new cottonwood trees.
Herm seemed to have difficulties forsaking the wonders of modern civilization so he had no meals planned at the put-in. We were all on our own until we launched. His personal plan was to eat all of his meals at the Marble Canyon Lodge. We brought along some ready-made hand food for our lunch, dinner and breakfast on launch day. This allowed us to enjoy Lees Ferry and delight in being back by the river. The next day Ranger Dave visited us at 9:30 AM for an hour, checked us for all the regulation stuff, and declared us ready-to-go after his safety presentation. After a bit of milling about and some last minute tie-downs, we pushed off at 11 AM. Unfortunately the 40 cfs sediment-laden Paria Creek just downstream muddies the 9,000 to 13,000 cfs clear green flows from the upstream dam! After lunch under the bridges, our group's first "test" was Badger Rapid at Mile 7.8. We decided to run without scouting; I'd informed folks earlier that the run was slightly left-of-center entry to center. Apparently this confused some as I drifted facing towards the big pour-over hole (you face the danger in a raft) before making a quick turn onto the tongue and into the downstream maelstrom. Herm led his lemming kayakers into the big pour-over, which caused some heavy bracing and rolling before the sheer fun of the several hundred yard long drop. We reached Soap Creek Camp at 3:00 PM, where we all enjoyed a great first night margarita party supplied by Herm.
So I became the river captain as desired. After a couple of days on the river, our group was in a "pocket" that minimized conflict with the numerous motorized commercial groups plying the river. We never overtook or were over-taken by another private group and we only had to play campsite bingo with a couple of commercial oared trips for a couple of days. Consequently, we were able to enjoy our first-choice campsites (with late morning sun and early afternoon shade in all but one instance). Most of the group seemed to be early risers. I heard there were folks staggering around hunting for coffee at 5:00 AM but I never wanted to check that out. Breakfast would be over and gear down to the rafts by 7:00 AM. Usually we would leave a bit after 8:00 AM but there were a couple of mornings when we were on the river by 7:30 AM. This insured that we were able to get our choice campsite of the day by 3:00 PM or so and enjoy hiking the side canyons. Several commented that they had never before enjoyed so many side hikes. Some certainly did a lot of hiking but I've been on trips that did more.
They tell me it gets light about 4:40 AM in the Grand Canyon in late May. I wouldn't know. By 5:00 AM the permit holder had his Kaldi's coffee brewing. I wouldn't really know about that either. Amazingly we were re-rigged and off the beach by 8:30 AM the first morning. Soap Creek Rapid was fun and everyone was looking forward to the Roaring Twenties. We carefully scouted House Rock Rapid from river left. Our kamikaze group ran the left side into the big hole successfully. The rest of us "cheated" it with a rock dodging run down the right. We had lunch near Rapid 21.5 and then the big water began. A humongous hole ate Herm and one of his kayaker friends for our group's first out-of-kayak experiences. There would be many more to follow. I think Herm had eight but I may have missed a couple. The hole at Indian Dick surprised Maury, flipping his 16' cleanly and quickly. After righting it on a sandy beach downstream, we spent an hour or so drying our 21-day supply of bread out before moving to camp at Upper Fence Rapid at mile 30.5. A twenty-mile day of paddling. The 8000 cfs water level actually made these rapids seem more difficult than normal. Indian Dick and Georgie's were especially tricky. This was the only day we didn't get our desired campsite (Shinumo Wash). Unfortunately it was taken by a commercial oared trip that passed while we were drying our bread. It gets dark at 8:00 PM and everyone was tired enough to be sound asleep by 8:30 PM. This pattern was to persist throughout the trip.
At breakfast the next morning an NPS river patrol trip came into camp with a video camera. Supposedly they were updating their footage for the Lees Ferry presentation. Since some were asked to sign releases, we may soon become famous. There was also the usual amount of how did you guys meet stuff going on. This could either be perfectly innocent conversation making or the never-ending search for those elusive pirate trips. Vasey's Paradise was pumping huge amounts of fresh water from the North Rim aquifer. We re-supplied. We had lunch at Redwall Cavern where Maury played us an Indian song on his flute. The next 13 miles passed quickly with relatively little whitewater. The normal upstream winds continued to be absent, unusual! We camped at Eminence Break just below President Harding Rapid. Later in the afternoon the NPS patrol trip came into our camp again and took video of one of the women using our three oar shower station set-up a few feet out in the river.
Most wanted to go hiking at Saddle Canyon the next day. Susan and I decided to drift down to Nankoweap immediately to miss any possible late morning winds. My everyday bailer, Georg, went hiking with the group so the two of us tied our two rafts loosely together and floated downstream with some raft bumping and scrubbing in the minor riffles. It was a short seven-mile day on 13,000 cfs to the main Nankoweap Campsite. After hiking at Saddle, Dave and Herm swapped rides, 14' NRS raft for a WaveSport Big EZ. One of the virtues of early camp breaks and short days was getting to hike in the afternoon. Herm hiked up Nankoweap Creek for 2.5 hours alone while most of the others climbed to the Nankoweap Granary. The view from the latter is probably the most photographed section of the Grand Canyon. Late May was still a good time to see the desert in bloom.
By now Herm's breakfast choices were becoming a standing joke. When quizzed later he told me he normally ate cereal for breakfast at home. He had somehow got it into his head that a group would not possibly thrive in the Grand Canyon unless they ate eggs every morning and sometimes even for lunch. When Lorie set up the menu with PRO I'm certain she planned pancakes, cereal, and other breakfast possibilities but Herm would not hear of it. We had to have eggs every morning on his trip of a lifetime, so we did. We had them scrambled, Benedict, over-easy, sunny-side up, cowboys assholes, French toast, with sausage, with Canadian bacon, with plain bacon, and on and on endlessly. What's for breakfast? Eggs! What's for breakfast tomorrow? More eggs. I still wonder how long it takes to clean out your arteries after nearly three weeks of eating two eggs a day. After another hearty, time-consuming breakfast, we floated down to the Little Colorado. We romped in the clear blue waters for an hour or so before floating two hours that afternoon down to Cardenas Camp. This was undoubtedly the hottest camp we stayed at. There was still no wind, which was making the 100F temperatures feel even hotter.
We left Cardenas by 8:30 AM on a 13,000 cfs flow. Just below camp was Unkar Rapid with big holes and waves everywhere at the top. If the coffee didn't wake them up, this rapid did! Neville's was run without any great difficulty and soon we were at the entry to the inner granite gorge scouting our first "really" big one, Hance Rapid. The rafters took a far left-to-center route using an eddy turn behind a big boulder. The kayakers thought another approach might be easier but it turned out to be a really long maelstrom of big hidden holes that tried to flip them. Sockdolager and Grapevine were scary for the kayakers because they couldn't be scouted and one can't see much sitting down at water level.
The trip seemed to be dividing into conservative and gungho boaters. As lead boat, I made conservative runs to insure someone was upright downstream. Rip, Susan, and Maury tended to do much the same but both Dave and Butch liked to challenge the biggest holes and usually did. By now the high number of out-of-kayak experiences had me convinced we had five intermediate kayakers with us. There had been much talk the first day about what the proper method was for being rescued by a kayaker but I'd noticed it was the rafters who were doing the rescuing. Indeed after one swim, one of the kayakers put his boat away on Rip's raft and became a rider for many days. The kayakers had figured out that Rip, Susan, and I were going to find an easy line if such existed so they were duplicating our runs most of the time.
We passed the large sand camp across from Vishnu Creek and proceeded on to Clear Creek hoping there would be enough sand for all of us. Still no appreciable upstream wind after six days! God certainly seemed to be on our side. And to make it even better, the Clear Creek site was great at the low water levels. Most hiked the side canyon for two hours getting back well before supper. Since we were not on the cook team Susan and I went up alone when it had cooled off a bit. About 6:00 PM we had thunder and ominous cloud cover with brief heavy wind gusts and a little sprinkle following.
This was exchange day so Butch, Naomi and Maury ferried Dale down to hike out at daybreak while we were to go down to the Phantom boat beach and await our incoming kayaker. We left Clear Creek at 8:30 AM and reached Phantom Ranch by 9:30 AM, with Dan arriving at 10:00 AM.
After filling all of our empty 6-gallon containers from the water tap near the beach, everyone took the walk up to the ranch and spent some time drinking $3.00 beer or $1.50 lemonade in the cantina. We had lunch at Pipe Creek. As there is no way to cheat it, Horn Creek Rapid at 8,000 cfs was expected to be challenging. Everything narrows down so once you commit to a particular line you are going to end up in nasty big holes and huge waves at the bottom. After the trip Herm rated Horn along with Lava, Hance and Granite as the biggest rapids he'd ever run. I might modify that to the biggest I've ever seen. We arrived at our Trinity Creek Camp at 2:30 PM. Thunderstorms with light sprinkles and an upstream wind created a great cooling effect for those hiking up the side canyon. While it had been expected that we would be sweltering in the somber, black granite gorge, we were experiencing a wonderfully cool evening.
Some of us awoke to moderate winds at dawn. I wouldn't know about that. The flows had been flat-lined at 8000 cfs for the Memorial weekend. I actually expected this to be good as Granite, Hermit, Crystal, and even the Jewels are a bit more forgiving at that level. Granite was an awesome force as usual; bigger than Horn with a huge eddy on the right. We ran straight down the right wall with no other choice available because the holes on the center to left were terrible. Herm reported being bowled over by a humongous wave requiring rolling up with two hundred yards of serious Class 9+ rapids left. I'm not certain whether he accomplished it or not. Unfortunately Rip must have been caught by the same wave and before he knew it his raft was upside down and he was a swimmer. Boat and boatman flushed out cleanly and we very quickly righted his raft and were under way again.
Hermit was a bit easier with a center-to-left move by the kayakers. I've developed a very reliable low threat run there that pulls sharply off the tongue to the right, surfs a large standing wave to drive me further right and then peacefully motors down the right side. It worked again. After Boucher, with a surprising hole about half way down that tried to fill my bailer boat, we scouted Crystal Rapid. Crystal was disappointing at 9,000 cfs. It was easily cheatable on the right and the left side was also open. Dave attempted the left run and ended up in the hole at the top as I had many years ago. After scrambling around on the raft to high side, he and Lori came through upright. The Gems (Tuna?, Sapphire, Turquoise, Ruby and Serpentine Rapid) hit us with surprising yet playful intensity. The prize for this lengthy, rapid-filled day was getting to North Bass camp by 3:30 PM. We weren't certain if there would be another group laid over there so we pulled in at South Bass where Maury was ran over the top and took a quick look, giving us the all clear signal.
Herm had wanted to do a couple of layover days but the pace to reach Phantom and exchange our people had been such that it was impractical. North Bass would be our first and only layover. I personally don't really believe anyone should lay over at major campsites but Herm wanted to do one and North Bass was definitely a great place to do it. Most of the group took W.W. Bass's high trail to his summer camp on Shinumo Creek the next morning and a shorter low-road river runner's trail in the afternoon. Everyone enjoyed this day off after the high anxiety of the inner gorge for the past few days. The kitchen team baked a marvelous cake to celebrate Susan Lupo's Birthday.
Another 9,000 plus cfs day, we launched at 7:30 AM so we would be the only group in Elves Chasm for a while. Waltenberg and Hakatai Rapids were run uneventfully. When we arrived at Elves a commercial motor trip was leaving so we lingered upstream a bit to give them time to vacate the creek mouth. Everyone scrambled up to the pool for photos and pool jumping. A few climbed above the first falls and explored the upper levels. This is definitely the kind of place that one can burn a lot of film. Fortunately most of our group seemed to be using digital cameras so that was not the problem it was at one time. The river slows down below Elves. After some drifting and rowing we reached Blacktail Canyon and went exploring. Not totally satisfied with the campsite there, we got back on the river and arrived at 122 Mile Camp by 3:45 PM after a long, fun-filled day.
We were off the next morning at 8:20 AM with a bunch of good rapids to run: Forester, Fossil, Specter, Bedrock, and the ever-ugly Deubendorff. Three motor-driven rafts were at the Doll's House when we arrived. With the low level, the river pulled hard to the rock in the middle of Bedrock with not much water on river right. All the rafts and all of the kayaks made it through the rapid without any problem. One raft went left. Deubendorff looked nasty as usual. The run was down the picket fence hoping to keep tight to it and end up in the center to right portion of the river downstream. The left looked really bad near the bottom. We had varying degrees of success accomplishing the plan. Somehow Susan cut loose into the big stuff on the left and ran it all successfully.
The motor group was on Stone Beach for lunch but wasn't planning on staying so we moved in and put up some shade cover. Another motor group dropped in a bit later for a clear water swim under the falls. In an effort to let the heat of the day pass, Susan and I set up the umbrella on my raft and read for a bit. Later we hiked up Stone Creek for a couple of miles. The flowers were pretty much done (people reported an excellent bloom in GC this April) but the barrel cacti were still blooming yellow and the cat's claw and mesquite smelled sweet. After 5:00 PM we had our first strong wind gusts which just about took out a few tents.
With our 5:00 AM maniacs in charge off the river, we got another early start. We were off by 7:45 AM this time because we were on a mission. This was a hiking day. Nine folks were going up Tapeats Creek to Thunder River, across Surprise Valley and down Deer Creek (Georg, Rip, Butch, Naomi, John S., Chris, Dan, Maury and Herm). This nine-mile hike through the desert required lots of water and an early start. Tapeats was running so strong that they were unable to cross it. This required a couple of boats to pull in at the head of the rapid for water resupply and the rest to take the hikers below the rapid so they would be on the right side of the creek. There was some confusion over Georg's boots so a couple of them got a later start than the rest. However it worked out fine and everyone eventually met us at Deer Creek.
We tied a raft onto the front of my raft and then had enough people to row all of the rafts down to Deer Creek. My extended raft was a bit unwieldy through Helicopter Eddy but other than that we had no significant problems. We stopped at Christmas Tree Cave so Susan Lupo could see it for the first time. It was pretty busy at the base of Deer Creek Falls so Suz and I boated down to Pancho's to get some shade for the boats and ourselves (it really helps to keep coolers in the shade when possible). The sun hit that beach pretty hard in the late afternoon so I took a walk down to check out the Back Eddy campsite and decided to move there. Just as I got back folks began to turn up so we were all camped at the Back Eddy by 4:00 PM with gusty winds but great shade. This was our first 17,000 cfs flow day.
We awoke to thunderstorms and everyone, including me, "slept in" half an hour. After drifting downriver for an hour or so we took a two-hour hike up Kanab Canyon followed by an hour hike at Matkatamiba. I was reluctant to run down to Matkatamiba first thing in the morning because I suspected the motor rafts would be there. Everyone enjoyed the short Kanab hike and by the time we reached Matkat the mouth was empty. It was adequate to get all of our rafts and kayaks into though a recent flash seems to have loaded it with debris, making it very shallow out some way into the river. We were fortunate to have it all to ourselves again. We continued on stopping to scout Upset Rapid. No one had trouble running this one hard right, although it was much bigger once committed than it looked ashore. We were blessed with another day without winds. We camped at Ledges to position ourselves for an early Havasu hiking day. The Ledges spring was running well so we refilled our water supply.
Again we were on the river early, allowing us to be at Havasu Canyon by 9:00 AM. Most of the group spent much of the day there, taking the two-hour hike up to the Havasupai reservation boundary and Beaver Cascade. Some swam most of the three miles back to the boats in the glorious, warm and clear waters. Although two motor trips had disgorged well over 50 people when we went past, just one motor group was frolicking in the first 300 yards of the creek when our folks returned to the boats. Susan and I took a leisurely start from the Ledges. We hiked up to check out the source of the spring and the pools that John had mentioned the previous evening. When the sun hit the Ledges campsite we floated our two boats down to National Canyon, along the way stopping in the shade of a large riverside ledge for an hour or so. Another windless day got the group reunited by 4:30 PM at the excellent National campsite.
Lava Falls day - very high anxiety. With most of the boats rigged, Herm was giving his friend guff for not helping Susan and I get rigged fast enough. I really wasn't in a particular hurry to get to Lava. The previous night I told Herm that we would be at Lava well before noon and that would be plenty soon enough for me. Regardless we were on the river at 8:00 AM with no wind again. This put us at Lava for scouting by 10:30 AM. We had done 15 miles in 2.5 hours on 11,000 cfs! After a half hour of scouting it was clear we were all going to run right and it might be pretty nasty. We would commit to the "bubble" lines on the right of the nasty ledge hole, slam the v-wave dead center, and attempt to keep the raft straight for the North Sea-sized waves below. The kayakers reported lots of excitement. Herm rolled twice to escape unscathed. John was flipped four times. Chris got flipped early and ran most of the rapid upside down before rolling. Dan had the "best" (no flip) run of kayakers. Susan made a great positioning run but got sucked out of her raft at the v-wave and got to swim the big stuff below. Her boat did fine. Ever-ready Georg jumped off my raft onto hers just above Son of Lava, pulled her back in and got her behind the oars just in time. We reached our camp at Upper Chevron by 1:30 PM. That night we had the traditional ABL (Alive Below Lava) party, celebrating Dave's birthday with a pineapple unside down cake.
Our first extremely windy day in sixteen and we had a lot of miles to make. I took Dan to the Whitmore helipad, arriving by 9:00 AM. We found Garth, the scheduler, a grizzled cowboy type from the ranch above, who committed to getting Dan off the river that day, even though he was a day early. The flat water rowing into the wind that followed was merciless. Any time a bit of whitewater appeared we all breathed a sigh of relief as the raft's downstream speed increased. We reached our planned camp at Granite Park by 2:30 PM, exhausted but elated to have put those gruesome miles behind us. After an hour or so a motorized trip came in to talk to us. A urgent message came down with the helicopters that Bob Marley needed to call someone. Unfortunately the guide lost the message and couldn't remember who I was supposed to call.
Our first thoughts were that one of our aging parents was ill, so we phoned both families on the satellite phone. They were all alive and well and glad to hear that we were also. The mystery deepened. All of a sudden a light bulb went off and we phoned the NPS. Since the message was two days old, they could only remember that it did not concern my immediate family. We were asked to call back in 15 minutes and learned that I was supposed to phone Bonnie Middleton. Unfortunately, my best friend Mike had died of a heart attack and the memorial was to be on the day we would get off the river. We immediately phoned Paul Lupo in Prescott and made plans to be picked up at Diamond Creek the next day around noon.
We pushed off at 7:30 AM with a stop at the Womb and Pumpkin Springs. We said our goodbyes to the group at Mile 222 around 11:00 AM. We figured Paul couldn't go from Prescott to Flagstaff and then get to Diamond before 12:30 PM and we didn't want to create a gigantic departure scene on the beach at Diamond. We also needed to get cleaned up and get clothes out. We waited an hour and then floated down to the Diamond Creek take-out. Paul was already there, having arrived 20 minutes earlier. It took us a couple of hours to derig the two rafts but by 8:00 PM we had returned Paul to his vehicle in Flagstaff, left a kayak and some other group gear at brother John's place in Flagstaff, and driven the 99 remaining miles down to Black Canyon City. It was a great trip and we were really sorry to have to leave early.
The rest of the group continued downstream with no major mishaps, enjoying great campsites along the way to South Cove. After the Middleton memorial service and reception Suz and I decided to meet the returning group and exchange some gear, so we hustled up to Flagstaff. Unfortunately, we missed Herm and his friends. Everyone had returned to Flagstaff, unloaded the trailer, and separated the gear by 4:00 PM so Herm's folks decided to try and make Albuquerque that evening. Lori, Dave, Rip, Maury, and the Lupos were still around so we celebrated another great trip with dinner at Busters. After a couple of hours of reconnecting we were off to Sedona.