2008 Trip Reports:
Grand Canyon Raft (4/1/08-4/16/08):
(Edited from the extensive notes provided by Ernie Hildner)
A few days before launch day we all piled into the Marleys' at beautiful Black Canyon City, Arizona. We kept busy pulling and sorting gear into appropriate piles. After which, Bob led a hike through the wilds behind his house. Yellow brittlebush flowers carpeted the desert, leaving yellow pollen trails on our legs. The next day, the garage floor was taped off into squares labeled for each day of the trip; cans, boxes and bags of food, distributed under Susan's watchful eye, were sorted by breakfast, lunch, or dinner, and labeled appropriately. Late in the day, one square at a time, the food was packed into rocket boxes that were labeled for the day the contents would be eaten. A day later some drove to Phoenix to pick up the van that would haul us to Lees Ferry. Others bought ice and dry ice for the coolers, and shopped for perishable food to fill them. Then back to BCC to pack the coolers, load and strap down the trailer.
Up early on April Fools Day, we had a quick breakfast and threw ourselves into the van, headed for Flagstaff to pick up the Canyon REO sixteen foot raft rented for Susan. At Lees, the usual Chinese fire drill ensued - unloading the trailer, blowing up boats, rigging frames, stowing impossible piles of stuff, etc. Ranger Dave Chapman arrived; our life jackets and the mandatory bits of equipment passed his inspection. Between rigging a rental raft and Bob's brand new sixteen foot NRS raft, it was late in the day when we finally threw the gear on and drifted down to the boater's camp, cooked dinner and fell asleep. We had the camp to ourselves as the other private group, outfitted by PRO, had dinner and spent the night at Marble Canyon Lodge.
At 9:00 AM the next morning Ranger Dave returned to check ID's and give us "the lecture". He warned that water releases would cause daily river fluctuation between 7K and 14K cfs at Lees; the Little Colorado was contributing another 2K cfs. The Paria was running just a bit. To estimate cycle times downriver, we could expect a flow between 4 and 5 mph. He also said that there are now 67 condors in and around the Park. We saw them soaring in the distance maybe half of the days but never had one close by. Underway in our three rafts and one kayak at 11:30 AM, we stopped three hours later at Soap Creek to camp. Some hiked up the drainage to a pouroff and enjoyed dripping water, blooming redbud trees, and rock formations.
Our second day on the river featured a five hour float to Silver Grotto to camp, with no scouting except at House Rock. The Roaring 20s lived up to their name. Mike bounced out of his rowing seat in Mile 24, but recovered nicely. About Mile 27, while Mike was enjoying the scenery and a Tecate, the boat parked on a barely covered sleeper rock, where it pirouetted and pinned, in the middle of the placid river. No amount of jerking or pulling or moving around on board freed it, so eventually Ernie put one of his long legs on the rock and - along with Mike's mighty heaves on the oars - successfully pushed off. No one went up into the grotto as we had all been there before and wading pools in the cool temps was unappealing.
A stop at Redwall Cavern convinced Kay to sing a bit. Another stop at Nautiloid Canyon gave Bob, Ernie, Sandy, and Brian the opportunity to carry buckets of water up the sketchy climb and around into the floor of the side canyon to see the numerous Nautiloid fossils weathering out of limestone. As we floated by, we noted the exploratory shafts for the two proposed dam sites and the Bridge of Sighs. We were again impressed by the treacherous location of the Anasazi Bridge. In camp at Eminence, folks compared their cracked finger tips and Susan began what became an almost nightly application of Crazy Glue. Brian walked around in his sandals that evening and by bed time had no skin on his feet. The rest of the trip he shifted immediately from kayak booties to hiking boots to protect his feet from the sand.
Since none of us wanted to hike to the Nankoweap granaries, we pulled in for lunch at the lower beach and then pressed on to the nice Awatubi camp. The wind varied from strong upstream gusts to periods of calm with occasional downstream wafts. It was gusty on the beach, blowing sand in a ground blizzard that quit by bedtime. Tamarisks provided very welcome wind shelter and shade. Ernie and Sandy hiked up Awatubi to a big pouroff, where there was a nice roof and blooming redbuds.
Off early, we skipped by the chocolate brown Little Colorado, envisioning it instead beautiful "Caribbean" blue and white. The rest of the trip we were in brown water, though the clarity improved daily. We saw backpackers at the upper end of Tanner Bar and below the Escalante Hilltop Ruin. Above Unkar, we encountered a private party of 8 kayaks with their 5 support rafts. Brian, our only kayaker, made friends and chatted them up. We camped early at the lower Nevill's Rapid camp. A first time Grand Canyon backpacker doing a Hance to Tanner loop joined us for lunch. Ernie, Sandy, Kay, Brian, and Thuy hiked up 75 Mile Canyon for a little over an hour, getting above the interesting Tapeats narrows. After it opened out, they could see lovely buttes and spires, and the rim. Alkali mobilized by the flush flow wrought havoc on our skin, our hands cracking badly as the trip progressed. We lathered our hands and feet with lotion or Vaseline at night and some slept in gloves. Most of us came home without fingerprints, no ridges on slick, smooth finger pads. It probably didn't help that the Little Colorado added lots of grit.
Furious winds and blowing sand made it impossible to cook dinner. So hunkered down on the boats, we imbibed in liquid refreshments and snacked. Ernie and Sandy's tent - with paco pads and half the contents of their river bags - pulled all of its pegs, upended, and threatened to take off in a gust. With everyone's help, the tent was relocated to a more sheltered site and tied off to vegetation. The gusts were so strong, one could hear them coming ten seconds before they hit. The recent four-day 40,000 cfs flush had deposited powdery new sand on many of the beaches. It was easily moved by even light wind and blew grit into everything, from food to tent zippers to orifices to clothes to dry bags.
Morning dawned windy enough that we had a cold breakfast. Susan was in extreme abdominal pain and hadn't slept all night, so we pushed off for the infirmary at Phantom Ranch. Ernie rowed Susan's boat against stiff winds, while Susan rode with Bob and Thuy, a nurse in real life. We scouted only Hance, where all the left side runs were adequate, although maybe not pretty. In the tail waves near the bottom of Grapevine, Bob hit a hole slightly crooked and went for a swim. Susan nearly joined him but Thuy pulled her back at a crucial moment. Susan jumped to the oars and after about a minute, they pulled a shivering Bob back aboard. After a few minutes rest Bob resumed rowing.
At Phantom, Bob and Susan immediately set off for the infirmary. Though Susan was feeling a little better, she was still considering leaving the trip. Della, the Phantom Ranger, proposed that we camp at the boat beach overnight. Susan could then decide whether evacuation by helicopter (a flight was scheduled the next day) or downriver by raft was best. Susan rested the remainder of the day, while the rest of the group enjoyed the Ranch lemonade or beer. We strolled and admired the amazingly clean people wandering the grounds. They must have showered after riding the mules down, because they sure didn't look like river runners or backpackers. The ever helpful Della came at dark and again in the gray dawn of the following morning to check on Susan.
Tired, but without pain, Susan decided to proceed downriver. Della assured her she could be lifted from a beach in the lower Canyon almost as easily as from Phantom. We hung around waiting for high water to make Horn Creek easier to run and before long there were 12 boats parked on the beach. Susan rowed from Phantom, through Horn and a bit beyond. Then Ernie rowed her boat while she rested. We lunched below Hermit at Schist Camp. More energetic as the day went on, Susan rowed until we stopped for the day at the upper Crystal camp. The recent flush flow left a steep bank of soft sand, ending in a two foot vertical sand cliff down to water level. After many trips up and down with gear, we eventually beat a diagonal trail across it.
The next day, there was a spit of worrisome rain as we finished breakfast and packed but it didn't develop into anything. After scouting again at the new water level, everyone had a great run. After Tuna, Mike gave Ernie the oars to run the "jewels", and all happily splashed through with "yippee!"s. Ernie underestimated the power of Serpentine and felt a bit thrashed there. We saw the old "Ross Wheeler" boat and Bass's cable crossing at South Bass. There was a little wind occasionally, but all in all it was delightful boating. We finished the day at Mile 110, which featured a delightfully easy exit from boats and a level carry to the kitchen. Threatening clouds drove us all to our tents after lunch, where the nap fairy found easy prey. It was a bit cooler with 50% cloud cover until the sun overcame the clouds in the late afternoon. The camp was littered with driftwood and since we were in fire season, we took advantage of the opportunity.
It was too cold to swim and we didn't have time to climb, so we floated past Elves Chasm without stopping. All agreed to run far right at Bedrock, to avoid being pushed to the wrong, left side of the "bedrock" that splits the flow. Bob went first, with Ernie; he chose such a shallow line that he bumped over some rocks, slowed momentarily, but then slid off into deeper water and continued. Susan must have been six inches farther right, because she encountered a rock which held the boat. Mike, coming down the same line with Kay, rammed Susan and pushed her more firmly onto her rock, possibly involving other rocks. Mike pivoted off Susan into deeper water and had no further trouble. Bob and Mike eddied out and while Kay held the boats, the guys walked back to the scene.
By the time they got there, Sandy and Thuy had scrambled to the back of the boat trying to ease it off the rock, as Susan flailed with her oars. Though the direction of pull would probably have been ineffective, Brian still heaved a throw line toward the boat, but it fell short. Next, the ladies tried hanging on the riverward side of the boat, holding onto straps and such while trying to get the maximum weight outboard. This didn't work, but after a number of pumps, and with Susan's strong exertions at the oars, the raft grudgingly shifted. As the ineffectual folks on shore cheered and crossed their fingers, it moved a bit more on the next pump by the crew. Gradually rotating out into the current, it ultimately slid free, right side up, with all passengers aboard, and no damage. Dubbed the "Bedrock Babes", the threesome was delighted to be afloat once more. The rest of the day was uneventful, though we got to watch a condor lazily make ascending orbits on a thermal until it broke off and headed up canyon perhaps 600 feet above us. Brian said he saw two more shortly thereafter. Since we could see a large group in the Galloway campsite and were unsure what might be at the out of sight Stone Creek below Dubendorff, we camped on the small beach at Mile 131.
Fair weather and light wind enhanced the Deubendorff scout and two of us successfully ran it just left of the picket fence while Mike pulled the big ride as he drifted further left. We filled our water jugs at Tapeats Creek and stopped at Deer Creek for lunch. The falls were running strongly, but we didn't hike into the narrows. We had planned to camp just below Kanab that evening, but Mike and crew didn't notice Ernie on the bank signaling them and sailed by. We didn't stop, but the pull-in pocket at Matkat seemed much smaller this year and possibly difficult to place many rafts into. It appears a debris flow may have filled it with gravel and rocks. We continued to Matkat Hotel, a much better camp than the one we missed.
We scouted Upset Rapid and tried to run right, as close to the rocks as possible. Bob and Ernie were kicked out by the current into the middle but hit the hole squarely. The 16 ft boat easily bridged across it and they were away into the tail waves. Susan touched a rock at the entry and spun out towards the middle, hitting the hole at a different angle. Her boat rolled up and ejected Kay, who couldn't quite reach the raft as Susan tried to row to her. Kay floated and stroked on her back, reaching shore as Susan, Mike and Thuy slid into a lower eddy. Brian paddled to Kay and towed her to Susan, where she reboarded. Adrenaline initially masked that Kay's left leg had been twisted or banged during the swim. It pained her to walk uphill for several days. The most humorous aspect of the swim was that Kay had been depantsed and didn't realize it until about a half hour afterwards. She entered the rapid wearing light blue splash pants over her wetsuit. During the swim they disappeared without a trace and without sensation.
Mike stopped briefly just above Havasu at what Tom Martin calls "Paradise", so Thuy and Ernie could walk up into a hanging glen with running water, about 100 ft above river level. There were lots of pretty flowers and rushes. Thuy saw a hummingbird in a tree by the water. They spooked a bighorn ram, driving it ahead of them. It was aggravated and making noises as it climbed the wall at the back of the glen. It appeared possible to continue, but they returned to Mike and his raft. Joining the group at Havasu, we snacked and some hiked a little upstream while others hung out in the sun or shade. The little cove at the outlet of clear flowing Havasu Creek was gorgeous, and there were some big (two foot long) fish visible swimming over the yellow bottom. We lunched downstream on a rock ledge, eventually continuing down to the lower National campsite. We had targeted upper National, but the recent flush denuded it of sand, leaving an unfriendly boulder field instead of a beach. It was warm enough now that we sought shade rather than sunshine during shore breaks and in camp.
We packed up and left camp in what Kay later described as "subdued" spirits, knowing that Lava Falls lay ahead. Aided by a slight tail breeze, we arrived at the scout before noon and formed a consensus on the line to follow. Bob and Sandy led and initially appeared to be on his chosen line but then Ernie saw one of Bob's famous white oars pointing vertically and waving, then vanishing. Mike, from his higher boatman's seat, reported the flip. Sandy was visible and Susan was heading toward the site of Bob's mishap, about to get thrashed. About that time Mike and Ernie got very busy on their boat and reports ceased as they skirted the ledge hole, went down the tongue sliding further left, blasted through a couple of serious waves, and enjoyed a super clean run.
Sandy swam strongly out to river right; Mike saw Bob near the overturned boat with Brian in hot pursuit. Mike pulled river right to pick up Sandy. Susan and Kay were okay, drifting downstream, but unable to reach Bob and the overturned boat before Son of Lava. Brian asked Bob to swim to the closest bank on river left, but Bob knew he was past Warm Springs and he was going to swim the next rapid no matter what. Son of Lava Rapid occurs because the river runs into, and is bent rightward by, an undercut wall which has much violence along it. One definitely would not want to be between a raft and the unforgiving wall, should the raft contact it. It was unsafe for Brian to run along side the overturned boat, so swimmer and raft continued through the rapid on their own. Brian chased down Bob's raft and tried to nudge it into an eddy several times, but it repeatedly drifted back into the current. After a mile or so of this, Susan and Kay got Bob onto her raft and made sure her raft remained downstream of his upended raft, no runaway boats allowed. Eventually Brian pushed the upended raft into another eddy on river right. This time it stayed but unfortunately its boatman was eddied out below on river left.
Passing "Tequila Beach", a big group was seen removing wetsuits and celebrating ABL (Alive Below Lava). They yelled, "Are there more bodies in the water?" "No", we yelled back and got a thumbs up. Astonishingly, by the time Mike got his raft tied to shore, the other party's seven boats were swarming the scene. Since they were 35-40 yr old, very fit Utah firefighters, accustomed to responding to emergencies and joyous at having an opportunity to right the boat, Mike decided they're were probably better at this than we were and told Ernie to "sit down, shut up, watch, and wait for orders." Brian - knowing better what was going on - was able to be of assistance. Once upright, Ernie hopped aboard and nothing appeared to be missing or broken. Water was later discovered in a couple of the boxes, Kay's river bag and one of the Marley paco pads. There was a little dampness in a Marley river bag, but both Bob's and Sandy's expensive cameras escaped unscathed. An oar tower had rotated a few degrees on aluminum tubing, which was easily fixed with an Allen wrench.
As the high-spirited firefighters gathered their gear, we thanked them profusely and were astonished when they thanked us. They had a layover day planned the next day and one of the activities scheduled was to practice flipping an overturned boat, which they had gotten out of the way. Mike and Ernie rowed the two boats, and Brian paddled, down to the opposite shore, where Bob had been pacing anxiously. Exactly two hours after arriving at the scout, we were having lunch, telling tales from various perspectives, and being exceedingly grateful that we got off so lightly. So much intensity compressed into so little time.
Amazingly, although Bob and Sandy rolled at the v-wave, hitting the right lateral wave and tilting up enough that the opposing, bigger left lateral caught the other tube and carried it under to instantly flip the boat, Bob didn't even lose his baseball cap or glasses. Susan, following Bob's line, but a little further left, hit the same lateral waves but apparently at a better angle. She was violently shaken, but the black side of the boat stayed down. Days later, it appeared that Bob wrenched his right knee and Susan took a hard whack in the back above her hip during this Lava melee. Sandy fared very well, and now she can brag that she swam Lava, a boast not many want to make.
At lunch we found a curvy piece of driftwood almost four feet long that another party had painted eyes and a lipsticked mouth on, emphasizing its coquettish form. Mike named her Agnes and took a great fancy to her, strapping her into a place of honor on his boat, taking her into his sleeping quarters at night, and eventually home to his wife Sue Ellen. Agnes was the inspiration for many low jokes during the rest of the trip. [Mike says that Sue Ellen greeted Agnes cordially enough, but soon banished her to the boat shed. We don't know if Mike is banned from conjugal visitation with Agnes.
After a warm night, we enjoyed still, gentle rafting. We stopped for lunch at a beach where a beaver had explored the back of the sand along the tammies, then crossed the beach and reentered the water, leaving interesting tracks. We repeatedly flushed three snowy egrets ahead of us as we floated. In early afternoon, the upstream wind suddenly hit hard, so we camped at Lower 202, a tamarisk-protected site. The wind picked up to gale force, scouring the beach of new sand. Sandy and Ernie were unsuccessful until Mike came up in his yellow Crocs and spotted the pictographs for them. They were nothing to write home about. The tamarisk wind break was a blessing as it blew all night. In the morning, a rocket box left near the water stood on a narrow three inch high pedestal, the sand not compacted by the box's weight having been scoured away by the wind. Brian's kayak, lying perpendicular to the wind, had windward and leeward dunes six inches high, with deep scour under bow and stern. The new sand was in most areas being reformed rapidly by the daily flow regime and the environmental effects of the flush, above water at least, are likely to be transient as the river reclaims its sand.
This day was a killer as we had to make the miles and the upstream wind never quit, only gusted more heavily occasionally. After 209 Rapid, Bob found himself caught by two large eddies. Susan caught up, then Ernie rowing Mike's boat caught up and the three of us played bumper boats, trying to get enough separation to row. Continually pushed into one or the other upstream eddies, the wind canceled any downstream flow. After a couple of feints, lucky Susan escaped. Ernie probed his options three more times before the addition of some of Mike's power helped them escape. Ernie and Susan hovered on a downstream bank, waiting 15 minutes for Bob, who eventually broke free when he and Brian took a line ashore and struggled through boulders, tugging the raft to downstream flow.
The gale pushed every raft off the wave-obscured current line, forcing the boatman to expend extra energy to get out of eddies. It often required "weathervaning" the rafts, pointing and pulling in a direction different from the desired downriver course or even the current. Brian couldn't read the eddy lines from river level, a real threat to his stability. He was concerned that if he was capsized by the wind, he might not roll up against it, and trying to roll with it, he would be blown down again. Worse yet, no raft might be able to reach him if he had to wet exit. It was an exhausting day for him both muscularly and psychologically. He finally took to paddling vigorously ahead, then waiting for us with one paddle firmly planted on the bank for support.
Stopping to regroup, we opted for snacks over lunch as we were working too hard to endure full stomachs. On a little sand bar, we saw about 20 beautiful avocets, hunkered down facing the gale. We planned to stop at 220 Mile Camp, but the highly favored upper camp was occupied. So, after struggling in the eddy above the island opposite the lower 220 Mile Camp (where we saw seven sheep including one little lamb grazing), we continued pulling downstream to 221 Mile Camp. Everyone was so glad to stop for the night. Susan literally lay in the boat apologizing for not being able to do anything for a few moments, not even to inspect the four new dime-sized blisters on her hands. The rowers and kayaker concurred a break from manual labor was needed for a while. The wonderful passengers, witnesses to the rowing and paddling effort expended all day, jumped to unload gear, carried it to camp, and quickly prepared a delicious dinner, bless them all. Bob later characterized it as "the hardest day I've ever spent on a river". All but Kay slept without tents - mostly too exhausted to set them up.
It was a beautiful and still last morning. Everyone was reluctant to dip their oars in the water and hasten the end of a wonderful trip. We reached Diamond, to find the Hualapai launching a big trip so we couldn't takeout early. Eventually with Susan schmoozing them, they let us onto the ramp about 15 minutes after our shuttle had arrived. The takeout was as usual a frenetic zoo of derigging, keeping gear separate, loading the trailer, strapping it all down, changing clothes and quickly departing. We started up the road before noon, thanking our lucky stars that we had been able to carry stuff off the boats directly onto a trailer parked at the river's edge.
The drive out of Diamond Creek was uneventful; we returned the rental raft to Canyon REO early and reached Black Canyon City in the late afternoon. Another hour and a half energetic flurry saw the trailer unloaded, Mike's frame disassembled and his gear loaded on his truck, the poop boxes dumped and washed, the food boxes washed and drying, and big piles gradually becoming smaller. Unexpectedly, most of the work was done and Mike was ready to go, so he and Agnes bugged out for home instead of staying overnight. The rest showered and went out to the Rock for dinner and some of the famous pie offerings.
The next morning, we worked a bit more on cleaning, sorting, and stowing gear. Brian and Thuy returned the rental van on their way to the airport and Kay drove off to visit with friends in Phoenix. Ernie and Sandy waited through lunch for tire balancing on their van before taking off for home, leaving the Marleys finally alone.
Overall the trip was too short, which made it more arduous. We needed to make miles, and with a party of 8 to complete all of the chores, we ate like horses, lost weight and gained muscle. The weather was excellent; with sun every day and only a couple threats of rain. Considering the season - the wind was not the problem it could have been, except one evening and that ridiculously windy next to the last day.